Urban Decay After Dark Palette ($49) shades in Alter, Sinful, and Lounge compared to Makeup Geek eyeshadows in Voltage and Havoc ($6 each), Makeup Geek foiled shadow in Untamed ($10), Johnny Concert eyelighter in Lust Dust ($13), JD Glow Shimmer Shadow in Papaya ($7.50 – 10% off with the code “DUPETHAT”), and Looxi shadow in Nirvana ($5 – 10% off with the code “DUPEDOLLS10”).

Urban Decay After Dark Palette ($49) shades in Fringe, Supersonic, Off Duty, Paralyzed, Druggie, and Scene compared to Makeup Geek foiled shadow in Caitlin Rose ($10), Johnny Concert eyeshadow in Smash Stereo ($13), Luxie eyeshadow in no. 246 ($6), Devinah eyeshadow in Illusion ($5 – 20% off with the code “DUPETHAT”), Morphe eyeshadow in Treasure ($2.29 – 10% off with the code “DUPETHAT”), and Maybelline Expert Wear eyeshadow in Pink Wink ($4).